FitYaf.com
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About Me
  • Fitness
    • Group Exercise >
      • How I Became an Instructor
      • Group Exercise Schedule
      • Class Reviews
    • Fitness Friday Workouts
    • At Home Workouts
    • Running >
      • Races
  • Nutrition
    • Shakeology® >
      • Shakeology Taste Sampler
      • Shakeology 3-Day Cleanse
      • Shakeology Sampler Pack
    • Beachbody Ultimate Reset™
  • Health and Fitness Coaching
    • Challenge Groups
    • Testimonials
    • Beachbody Promotions
    • Shop

The problem with believing everything you read

1/14/2014

3 Comments

 
If you've read my 'about me' page, you know that during the day, I am a bioengineer.  I'm currently doing work on magnetic targeted endothelial cell delivery to stented arteries.  During the day, I read journal articles, culture cells, analyze tissue and write up my findings in the form of manuscripts and grants, so I can get more money to keep doing what I'm doing.  At night, I teach group exercise classes.  It's a nice change of pace, and in most ways, completely different from what I do during the day.  But every once in a while, my two worlds collide, and I can use my training as a scientist to take a look at the world of health and fitness.
To give you a little background, I don't follow a specific "diet".  I try to make the best choices for myself, my health and fitness goals, and that might be different than the choices you make for yourself.  In general, I'm not against "diets" - if you find something that works for you, I'd encourage you to stick with it.  If you tell me you feel better and hit your goal weight by removing gluten from your diet - excellent!  If you tell me dairy makes you feel bloated, then don't eat it!  If you tell me that you eat 2 pounds of butternut squash to carb-load for your long runs while marathon training, so be it (oh, wait, that's me)!  So when people ask me about the Paleo Diet, the only advice I have is to give it a try if you're interested.  If you're goal is losing weight, you'll know relatively quickly if it's working for you.  But, if your goal is to prevent heart disease, well, you may never know if it's "working".
Over the weekend, I came across a twitter post linking me to this article by Chris Kresser on MindBodyGreen.  The title of the article is, "5 Things Everyone Gets Wrong About Paleo".  Since I do like to educate myself on the current health and fitness trends, and I admittedly don't know everything about the Paleo Diet, I wanted to read on.  I don't have much to say about #2 through #5 on the list, but #1 struck a nerve with me.
Myth #1: "Our Paleolithic ancestors all died before they were 30."
Critics of Paleo often proclaim: “Why should we emulate the diet of our ancestors when they all died before they were 30?” While it’s true that the lifespans of our Paleolithic forebears were shorter on average than our lifespans today, those averages don’t consider significant challenges those ancestors faced that are largely absent from our modern lives. These include high rates of infant mortality, tribal warfare and violence, exposure to the elements, and lack of emergency medical care.

Studies show that when these challenges are taken into account, our ancestors (as well as contemporary hunter-gatherers) lived lifespans roughly equivalent to our own. But more important, they reached these ages without developing any of the chronic, inflammatory diseases like obesity, diabetes, heart disease or autoimmune disease that plague us today.

I didn't read the referenced study word for word, but I read it enough to know that the study is referring to "modal age", where a year is not the time it takes for the earth to circle the sun.  It's an "age equivalent".  So to say that our hunter/gatherer ancestors lived to the same age as we are living today is a little misleading.  Also, in addition to a decreased rate in infant mortality, tribal warfare and violence, etc., we also have EXTREME lifestyle and environmental differences, when compared to our ancestors, making it difficult to isolate any specific reason for a change in disease prevalence.  Furthermore, our knowledge today on chronic, inflammatory diseases is MUCH more than it was "back then", and to say that we can get a complete medical profile from our ancestors' remains is an insult to current medical research.

I think most people are in agreement that genetics play a large role in the development of some diseases.  Let's not forget that our genetics have been shaped by our ancestors.  Who's to say that the very diet our ancestors lived off of altered our genetics in such a way to make us more susceptible to certain diseases?  It's a little "out on a limb", but the point I'm trying to make is that there is too much unknown to really draw any solid conclusions.
Do I think that switching from a "typical American diet" to the Paleo Diet can improve your health?  Absolutely!  There are a lot of really great things about the Paleo Diet, and I agree that your diet plays a huge role in your overall health.  But, I'm not so quick to agree that wheat and dairy are the direct cause of chronic, inflammatory diseases like obesity, diabetes, heart disease and autoimmune diseases.  I think we're making a lot of progress in figuring out how to best nourish our bodies, and it seems like the even the USDA is making changes in their recommendations.  But, at the end of the day, it's probably best to take everything you read with a grain of salt (although not literally, because salt is bad for you, right?).

So what does FitYaf recommend?

  1. Eat what makes you feel good
  2. Don't eat what makes you feel bad
  3. Move every day
  4. Don't eat to the point where you're uncomfortably full
The problem with believing everything you read - FitYaf's recommendations
Anything beyond that depends on your goals, your personal situation and your genetics.  But don't just believe me because you read it here - educate yourself!  And Chris, no hard feelings - you are inspiring SO many people to get healthy!  Keep at it!
What are your thoughts about the Paleo Diet?
3 Comments

New Shakeology Flavor - Strawberry!

1/7/2014

0 Comments

 
Big news over at Beachbody - there's a new Shakeology flavor in town!
New Shakeology Flavor - Strawberry!
This new Strawberry flavor is much different from the vegan Tropical Strawberry.  This flavor is made with whey protein (so not grainy and thin like the vegan Tropical Strawberry flavor) and has a much fuller strawberry flavor!

Even better news is that you can now get a Neapolitan combo pack, with Chocolate, Vanilla and Strawberry.  This is a great way to drink Shakeology and add some variety to your normal routine!
New Shakeology Flavor - Strawberry!
This flavor isn't out until January 13th, but feel free to contact me or comment below if you have any questions!
0 Comments

    Jillian [FitYaf]

    fitness enthusiast.
    coach.
    marathoner.
    bioengineer.

    Fit Approach
    FitYaf's Bulu Box
    Picture
    FitFluential Is Fitness Found

    Archives

    February 2015
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013

    Insanity Certification

    Categories

    All
    21 Day Fix
    At Home Workouts
    At Home Workouts
    Beachbody
    Bodypump
    Bulu Box
    Burpee
    Cardio
    Challenge
    Charity
    Choreography
    Crossfit
    Diva Dash
    Fall
    Family
    First Blog Post
    Fit
    Fitmapped
    Fitness
    Fitness Challenge
    Fitness Challenge
    Fitness Friday
    Fitness Friday
    Fit Pregnancy
    Fityaf
    FitYaf Answers
    Focus T25
    Friends Of Fityaf
    Friends Of Fityaf
    Gadgets
    Group Exercise
    Group Exercise
    Group Fitness
    Group Fitness
    Half Marathon
    Healthy Eating
    Healthy Eating
    Healthy Habits
    Healthy Habits
    Les Mills Bodypump
    Low Impact
    Marathon
    Music
    Nickname
    P90
    P90x
    Paleo Diet
    Parties
    Party
    Philly Phitness Tour
    PiYo
    Pregnancy
    Pull Up
    Pull Up
    Pull-up
    Pushup
    Race
    Recipe
    Richard Simmons
    Running
    Shakeology
    Shakeology Recipes
    Shaun T
    Soulmate Workout
    Spinning
    Step Aerobics
    Strength
    Summer
    SweatSync
    Travel
    Treadmill
    Weight Loss
    Weight Loss
    Winter
    Workout
    Yoga

    RSS Feed

    To my readers, please note this website and blog is for educational and informational purposes only. For medical advice, dietary restrictions, and/or medical diagnosis, and before beginning any diet and/or exercise program, please consult a doctor or healthcare professional. 
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.